2026, Issue 1 (September)

The Material Price of Easier Meadow Establishment: Sand Depth, Weeding Demand and Forb Retention

by
1University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada

Sand capping may reduce the maintenance required during urban meadow establishment, but additional material does not necessarily deliver proportional labour savings. This study compares three cap depths and examines whether jute reduces weeding demand while maintaining forb establishment. Weeding time was accumulated across six visits to 54 randomized plots in Royal Park, Melbourne, and twelve-month forb richness was assessed from four pooled quadrats per plot. Labour budgets were compared with nominal construction quantities, with uncertainty estimated from 50,000 whole-plot bootstrap resamples. Without jute, mean cumulative weeding demand was 19.44 hours per 100 m2 on uncapped soil, 9.76 at 10 mm and 4.65 at 80 mm. The first cubic metre of sand saved 9.68 hours, while the additional seven cubic metres saved 5.10 hours. Increasing the cap from 10 to 80 mm therefore broke even at an installed sand cost equivalent to 0.729 labour hours per cubic metre, with a 95% percentile interval of 0.380–1.164. At the deepest cap, adding jute reduced mean weeding time by 0.37 hours, although the uncertainty interval included zero, and pooled forb richness was 2.11 species lower. Richness differed little among treatments without jute, but these similarities did not establish ecological equivalence. Variation across visits and the observed labour distributions also indicated that construction choices influenced when work was required and how strongly demand was concentrated. The deepest cap produced the lowest measured weeding demand, while the initial sand increment delivered the greatest saving per unit of material. Meadow specifications should assess successive construction increments, evaluate forb establishment separately and base financial expectations on the observed establishment period.

Floristic Complementarity and Single-Site Loss in the Stewardship of Small Urban Green Spaces

by
1Department of Landscape Architecture, Westhaven University, Oregon, USA
2School of Architecture and Environmental Design, Lakecrest University, Michigan, USA
3Department of Urban Design and Landscape Studies, Cedarbridge Institute of Design, Colorado, USA
4School of Architecture and Planning, Fairmont Coast University, California, USA
5University of Alaska Fairbanks, Fairbanks, AK 99775, USA

Selecting urban vegetation patches solely by local taxon richness may overlook their combined floristic contribution and the consequences of losing an individual site. This study examines whether balanced selections of small urban green spaces can improve taxon representation while retaining coverage after a single-site loss. Vegetation observations from 90 sites in three Finnish cities support an exhaustive comparison of 15,625 eligible six-site combinations per city. Each combination includes one urban and one suburban example of traffic islands, road verges and parking-area vegetation. Selection criteria prioritize summed local richness, total taxon coverage or the minimum coverage remaining after any single-site deletion. Across 93 taxa, including nine identified only to genus, the highest-coverage selections represent 33 of 47 taxa in Helsinki, 32 of 45 in Tampere and 45 of 66 in Turku. Maximizing coverage and protecting the worst-case remainder produce coincident optima in Helsinki and Tampere. In Turku, reducing initial coverage from 45 to 44 taxa increases the minimum remainder from 36 to 38. This trade-off persists when genus-level entries are excluded and when taxon occurrences are reconstructed from quadrat observations, but disappears when a 1% mean-cover threshold is applied. The findings support transparent comparisons of alternative stewardship selections, pollinator benefits or intervention effects. Landscape planning should therefore identify which taxa are exchanged between alternative selections and assess sensitivity to sparse occurrences before treating vegetation patches as interchangeable.

When Group Rankings Conceal Listener Disagreement

by
1Department of Landscape Architecture, Qinglan University of Design, Hangzhou, China
2School of Architecture and Environmental Design, Huaming Institute of Technology, Nanjing, China
3Department of Urban Landscape Planning, Dongyuan University, Suzhou, China
4School of Architecture and Built Environment, Yunhe University of Arts, Chengdu, China

Auditory recordings allow landscape experiences to enter design discussion, but stable group averages may conceal changes in individual comparisons. Thirty listeners assessed four settings in stereo and binaural presentations using three seven-category presence items. This investigation calculated matched format differences, classified within-listener setting contrasts as retained, reversed or tied, and examined sensitivity to incomplete answers, scoring and presentation position. Complete responses supported 110 format pairs and 150 cross-setting comparisons. Average binaural-minus-stereo differences ranged from −0.47 to 0.17 points, with all listener-bootstrap intervals crossing zero. The ordering of setting means was unchanged, yet 41 comparisons reversed, corresponding to 27.3% of available comparisons and 32.5% of comparisons with strict orderings in both formats. Sixteen reversals retained contrasts of at least one point in both presentations. Equal listener weighting yielded 25.0%, while restriction to fully observed listeners yielded 30.8%. Median scoring reduced reversals and increased ties, demonstrating dependence on comparative resolution. The observations establish that preserved aggregate ordering does not guarantee preserved individual judgments. They do not identify a causal format effect because each setting was presented only once per format, and no on-site counterpart was assessed.

Call for Papers

Electronic Journal of Landscape Architecture invites submissions for Volume 2026, Issue 4, scheduled for publication in September 2026. The journal welcomes high-quality scholarly contributions that advance research, theory, criticism, and applied knowledge in landscape architecture and related fields.

News

Indexing